Red Flags and Financial Ratios for Nonprofits
Effective board oversight requires understanding key financial indicators. This session covers essential nonprofit financial ratios, their interpretation, and the board's role in risk governance. Monitoring these metrics helps boards spot early warning signs (red flags) of financial distress or inefficiency, ensuring proactive risk management.
Key Financial Ratios for Nonprofit Boards
Program Expense Ratio
(Program Expenses / Total Expenses) x 100%. Measures the percentage of spending dedicated to mission activities versus overhead (admin/fundraising).
Significance: High ratio (e.g., >75% per Charity Navigator, >65% per BBB Wise Giving Alliance) often indicates mission focus. Too high (>95%) might signal underfunded infrastructure. Boards monitor this for balance and trends (a dropping ratio needs explanation). Know your number and sector norms (check 990/Annual Report).
Fundraising Efficiency (Cost per Dollar Raised)
Fundraising Expenses / Contributions. Shows the cost to raise $1.
Significance: Lower cost is generally better (e.g., <$0.20 - $0.25 per $1 raised, or >4:1 ROI). Boards assess if fundraising is cost-effective. Context matters (e.g., new donor acquisition costs more initially). Track trends and ensure transparency (visible on Form 990). High costs can be a red flag.
Operating Reserve Ratio (Months of Liquid Reserves)
Unrestricted Liquid Net Assets / Average Monthly Expenses. Measures how long the organization could operate without new income.
Significance: Indicates financial stability. Boards often set targets (e.g., 3-6 months). Low reserves (<1 month) are a major red flag. Healthy reserves provide cushion; very high reserves might prompt discussion about deploying funds to mission. Know your "runway."
More Essential Financial Ratios
Debt Ratio / Leverage
Total Liabilities / Total Assets. Assesses reliance on debt.
Significance: High ratio indicates potential over-leverage. If >100%, liabilities exceed assets (insolvency risk). Boards must monitor any debt, ensuring payments and compliance with loan covenants. Larger orgs might track Debt Service Coverage.
Administrative Expense Ratio
Administrative Expenses / Total Expenses. The percentage spent on management and general functions.
Significance: Complement to the program ratio. Boards monitor for reasonableness – avoiding both bloat and underinvestment in essential infrastructure. Track changes year-over-year. Be aware of this for accountability, despite the sector's move towards outcomes focus.
Revenue Concentration Ratio
Measures dependence on a few funding sources (e.g., % of revenue from top funder).
Significance: High concentration (e.g., >25-50% from one source) signifies risk. Boards should be aware of major dependencies and encourage diversification where feasible.
Operating Margin
(Total Revenue - Total Expenses) / Total Revenue. Measures operational surplus or deficit.
Significance: Consistent deficits are unsustainable. Small positive margins (0-5%) are often healthy, allowing for reinvestment or building reserves. Large surpluses warrant discussion. Boards track for long-term financial health.
Additional Financial Metrics to Monitor
Liquidity Ratio (Quick Ratio)
(Cash + Short-term Investments + Receivables) / Current Liabilities. A stricter measure of ability to meet short-term obligations.
Significance: Ratio <1.0 suggests potential cash flow issues. >1.0 is preferable; very high might indicate idle assets.
Donor Retention Rate
% of last year's donors who gave again this year. A key fundraising health metric.
Significance: High retention signals donor satisfaction and future revenue stability. Low retention is a red flag for engagement and long-term funding. Boards should monitor this.
Revenue Mix & Program Sustainability
Ratios examining earned vs. contributed revenue (overall or per program).
Significance: Helps understand reliance on philanthropy vs. self-generated funds and identifies programs requiring significant subsidy. Important for strategic decisions.
Interpreting Financial Indicators
Compare
Are we meeting targets or industry benchmarks?
Analyze Trends
Are ratios improving or worsening? Why? (e.g., dropping program ratio due to needed infrastructure investment vs. inefficiency).
Act
Do the ratios signal a need for action? (e.g., build reserves if liquidity is low, reassess fundraising if costs are high).
Board members typically receive these ratios in financial reports or dashboards (e.g., "Program Ratio: 78%; Months of Cash: 3.2; Operating Margin: +3%"). The board's role is interpretation through this three-step process.
Spotting Financial Red Flags
Critical Concerns
Negative unrestricted net assets (potential insolvency)
Serious Issues
Consecutive operating deficits, dwindling liquidity, rising debt levels
Monitoring Needed
Declining program ratio, high fundraising costs, funding concentration
Early Indicators
Growing receivables, cash flow struggles, frequent credit line use
Ratios act as vital signs; poor or deteriorating trends are red flags demanding attention. Monitoring these helps the board act proactively, much like a doctor intervening based on concerning health indicators.
Risk Governance: Board Oversight and Practices
Establish Framework
Adopt a risk management policy or assign clear risk oversight duties (often to Audit/Finance Committee). Define the organization's risk appetite (tolerance levels for different risk types).
Identify & Prioritize Risks
Ensure management identifies key risks (e.g., funding loss, fraud, data breach, safety issues, reputational harm, compliance failure). Use tools like a risk register/matrix (likelihood vs. impact) to prioritize. Discuss mitigation plans.
Integrate with Strategy
Embed risk assessment into strategic planning. Evaluate risks associated with major initiatives before approval. Ask: "What could derail our goals?"
Oversee Controls & Compliance
Ensure strong internal controls to prevent fraud/errors. Monitor compliance with laws and regulations. Ensure accountability for compliance.
Monitor External Environment
Stay aware of external factors and ensure the organization adapts. Encourage contingency planning.
Ensure Adequate Insurance
Verify appropriate insurance coverage is reviewed and updated annually. Insurance is a key risk mitigation tool.
Require Regular Reporting
Receive periodic risk updates. Ensure prompt notification of significant risk events. Foster a culture of transparency.
Document Mitigation Measures
Confirm plans are documented for key risks (e.g., emergency plans, crisis communication, succession plans, data backups, cross-training).
Conclusion: Proactive Guardianship
Ask Key Questions
"What might stop us or harm us, and what are we doing about it?"
Use Risk Frameworks
Likelihood/Impact matrix helps focus efforts on critical risks
Protect the Mission
Ensure the nonprofit is resilient and prepared for challenges
Effective risk governance shifts the board from reactive problem-solving to proactive guardianship. By asking "What might stop us or harm us, and what are we doing about it?", boards protect the mission. Using frameworks like the Likelihood/Impact matrix helps focus efforts on the most critical risks. Ultimately, strong risk oversight ensures the nonprofit is resilient and better prepared to navigate challenges, safeguarding its ability to serve its stakeholders.
Nonprofit Board Governance Guide
This comprehensive guide breaks down nonprofit governance into eight essential sections.
Whether you're new to board service or a seasoned leader, you'll find valuable insights.
Ditch the Email Chaos. Manage Your Nonprofit Board the Smart Way.
Tired of scattered documents, endless email threads, and tracking down votes? Quorum brings everything your board needs into one secure, affordable platform.
Lost Files?
Centralized dashboard with secure AWS S3 document storage keeps everything organized.
Meeting Mayhem?
Integrated agendas, notes and decision logging with rich text editing.
Voting Hassles?
Secure online voting with anonymous options, receipts and easy tracking.
Just $20/Board/Month with unlimited members included. No per-user fees.